In this week's comments update, readers are discussing a skyscraper designed by David Chipperfield Architects and sharing their views on other top stories.
David Chipperfield Architects's latest New York project is The Bryant, a 32-storey mixed-use concrete skyscraper in Midtown Manhattan.
The British studio undertook the project for New York-based developers HFZ Capital Group. The building overlooks Bryant Park and the New York Public Library.
"Tough crowd here"
Readers are divided. "Boring and indistinguishable," said Jack Woodburn on one hand. "It looks like scores of buildings across America."
David disagreed: "Tough crowd here! I think this building does a great job. It's subtle, which I think is the right way to go for this location and height. It's timeless. All materials feel high-end in an understated way, which I find the ultimate luxury. Not all architecture needs to scream or be iconic." "I think it's a very appropriately designed building," added Good Job. "It's not trying to compete with the architectural landmarks in the surrounding area."
"Two kinds of folks in the discussion," concluded Erik Boehlo. "Those who want to go to Mars and those that prefer Earth. Martians want new, excitement, gratification at all costs. Earthlings are contextual, nuanced, content. Fabulous building."
Are you a fan of The Bryant" Join the discussion ?
Mizzi Studio builds coffee kiosk with "a...